Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC (ASIC)
Financial Services
- Fundamental
- 4
- Sentiment
- 2
- Technical
- 2
Do Nothing: qualitativeScore is 2 (below the required floor of 3 — upstream moderate red flag of sharp sentiment deterioration with no rewarded bullish catalyst) and the 20-day average dollar volume of ~$2.28M is below the $5M liquidity floor; no bullish entry is admissible on this name.
Company overview
Ategrity Specialty Holdings LLC provides insurance and reinsurance services for small and medium-sized businesses in the U.S., focusing on property and casualty insurance. Founded in 2017, it is headquartered in New York and operates as a subsidiary of Zimmer Financial Services Group LLC.
Fundamental
goodAtegrity shows strong revenue growth and underwriting profitability, with a reasonable earnings multiple and no material debt.
Ategrity’s SEC-reported results show a profitable, fast-growing E&S P&C insurer: FY 2025 revenue was $424.34M (up from $343.83M in FY 2024) and 1H 2026 net income reached $58.92M. Underwriting remains profitable (combined ratio below 100%), book value is rising, and filings indicate no material debt. On reconstructed trailing earnings, valuation looks reasonable (P/E ≈ 11.26; EV/Sales ≈ 2.17). Key risks center on catastrophe/claims severity (“social inflation”), reinsurance availability/pricing, and controlling-shareholder governance.
Sentiment
weakRecent earnings miss and price-target cut have led to a negative sentiment, overshadowing positive underwriting results.
The Q3 2026 earnings print (announced, 2026-10-21) is the dominant catalyst and is clearly bearish on reception, not on issuer framing: revenue of $127.1M landed below the $133.3M FactSet estimate, adjusted earnings fell, investment losses offset underwriting gains, and shares dropped roughly 15% on 2026-10-22, followed by a 12-month price-target cut to $28.8 — the constructive underwriting data (record combined ratio, gross written premiums +15% to $165M, Q4 growth guided 15–20pp above the E&S market) shipped inside the same print the tape sold. Sentiment delta is indeterminate (the baseline window produced only two unique on-topic scored items, so no numeric comparison is computable), and a moderate red-flag cap applied for sharp ≤14-day sentiment deterioration with no offsetting rewarded bullish catalyst; the severe screen was clear.
Technical
weakThe stock has experienced a gap-down with weak recovery, remaining below key moving averages and showing no clear trend.
Score 2 — the chart is a post-earnings breakdown with only a tentative bounce. Price 24.11 sits below SMA20 26.19, SMA50 26.46, EMA9 25.91, EMA21 26.24, WMA9 26.03, WMA21 26.17, DEMA14 25.76 and TEMA14 25.47, and only just above SMA200 22.24 and the 23.84 VWAP. RSI 37.9 and Williams %R -78.4 show weakness without a confirmed reversal; MACD has just crossed down (line -0.22 vs signal -0.02, histogram -0.20); ADX 18.7 confirms no established trend in either direction. The 2026-10-22 session was a ~3.6x-volume distribution day that swallowed the entire 25.6-28.0 shelf built since mid-September. That is a bounce-only, weak-bearish structure, not a tradable 1-15 day long setup — and the trade is hard-blocked regardless by qualitativeScore 2 (floor 3) and a 20-day dollar-volume average of ~$2.28M against the $5M floor.
You’re looking at 2026-10-23 — more than 2 trading days ago.
Subscribers saw this then, and see today’s score, verdict and trade plan now.
More Financial Services
Not financial advice. For informational and educational purposes only.

